Comparison of taking coconut oil capsules for weight loss versus off the spoon chased with water before meals.
Coconut oil capsules are a very popular substitute for consuming this healthy fat.
Is the convenience of capsules as beneficial or effective as off the spoon or mixed with a beverage or food?
This is an especially important question when using coconut oil for weight loss as larger amounts are consumed before meals as an appetite suppressant.
Let’s examine both the pros and cons of consuming one of nature’s healthiest fats in capsule form instead of traditionally as a liquid.
Pros of Coconut Oil Capsules
Below are the reasons for using coconut oil capsules instead of the straight liquid for health and weight loss purposes.
Semi-Solid Confusion
One of the most confusing things about coconut oil is how it switches from solid to liquid depending on the temperature.
This alarms some people into thinking that the oil has somehow gone rancid and shouldn’t be consumed.
Coconut oil is naturally liquid at temperatures over 76 °F/ 24 °C.
Conversely, coconut oil will go from liquid back to solid at temperatures below 76 °F/ 24 °C.
This switching back and forth from solid to liquid and then back again does not harm coconut oil.
In fact, this tropical fat is highly resistant to rancidity perhaps more so than any other fat on the planet.
As an example, I keep a 5-gallon bucket of coconut oil in my garage which regularly gets over 100°F/ 28°C during the summer and sometimes below freezing in the winter. It keeps perfectly for years!
All of this confusion ends when using coconut oil capsules. Whether the coconut oil is liquid or solid within the capsules is usually not even noticed by the person taking them.
In addition, the expiration date on the bottle provides a certain level of assurance that the product is safe.
The concerns about whether the coconut oil is fresh or better to take as a solid or liquid become immaterial when using capsules.
Travel
Another benefit of coconut oil capsules is that they are very convenient and helpful for traveling.
Oil of any sort in a jar or bottle seems to have a way of leaking out in hand luggage or your checked suitcase. Stained clothes with a big mess is a definite risk.
No matter how tightly you screw on that lid, a little bit always seems to leak out! And, when it comes to oil, even a small amount can do quite a bit of damage.
Traveling with capsules instead of jarred liquid eliminates this problem.
Small Dosage
Perhaps the best use for coconut oil capsules is that they conveniently allow for smaller dosages that can be incrementally increased over time.
This is particularly helpful for those taking coconut oil for the first time who experience gastric distress or diarrhea.
These symptoms tend to occur more often for those who have been following a lowfat diet for a long time or who have gut imbalance.
Coconut oil is highly anti-microbial, with the die-off of pathogens from the sudden adoption of daily coconut oil consumption very possible.
A myriad of unpleasant detox symptoms can occur for a short period of time.
Thus, if you are considering using coconut oil as a weight loss supplement for the first time, going slow with capsules to start is a good idea to consider.
Note: if nausea or other gastric distress still occurs even with small doses, using herbal bitters can help.
The Downside of Capsules
Coconut oil capsules come in various sizes. The most common size I have seen is 1000 mg (1 gram).
A few of these capsules each day works fine if you simply want to add some healthy fat to your diet in small amounts.
However, if you want to take larger amounts to slim down, capsules don’t work so well.
For example, using coconut oil for weight loss involves consuming fairly significant amounts approximately 20 minutes before each meal.
Prior to eating is the best time to consume it (virgin or expeller pressed as desired).
The effect is a significant reduction in appetite to help you feel full more quickly with a smaller portion size.
How Much Liquid Coconut Oil to Take
Blending 1-2 tablespoons of coconut oil in a mug with hot water, bone broth, or herbal tea is suggested when taking coconut oil therapeutically.
Note that bulletproof coffee is not advised.
Simply stir to melt the semi-solid oil in the hot beverage and then drink.
The following guidelines outlined by the book Eat Fat, Lose Fat determine how much to consume before each meal:
- 90-130 lbs, use 1 Tbsp coconut oil before each meal for a total of 3 Tbsp per day.
- 131-180 lbs, use 1.5 Tbsp coconut oil before each meal for a total of 4.5 Tbsp per day.
- Over 180 lbs, use 2 Tbsp coconut oil before each meal for a total of 6 Tbsp per day.
Capsules Equivalent
Calculating the amount of coconut oil needed for weight loss into the capsule equivalent is staggering!
The amounts are summarized below (I used this conversion calculator):
- 90-130 lbs, use 15 coconut oil capsules (1000 mg/1 gram each) before each meal for a total of 45 capsules per day.
- 131-180 lbs, use 22 capsules of coconut oil before each meal for a total of 66 coconut oil capsules per day.
- Over 180 lbs, use 30 capsules of coconut oil before each meal for a total of 90 coconut oil capsules per day.
Coconut Oil Capsules Are Impractical
It’s obvious when you sit down and do the math that using coconut oil capsules for weight loss is impractical.
This is due to the huge number of capsules that are required each day. Even a person who weighs 130 pounds or less would take over 3 dozen per day!
It is unrealistic to consider taking 45+ capsules of coconut oil every day for weeks on end while weight loss goals are pursued.
It would get rather expensive too! Most of the brands of coconut capsules I checked cost about $10 for 120 capsules. Nearly an entire bottle would be used every other day.
Compare this to purchasing a quart of virgin coconut oil for not much more that would last about two weeks.
Buying coconut oil in larger amounts would prove even more cost-effective compared with capsules.
Skip the MCT Oil Capsules Too
When considering quality coconut oil for health or weight loss, don’t be fooled by the clever marketing behind liquid coconut oil or “MCT oil”.
MCT oil is best avoided in all forms including capsules.
This is because it is an adulterated product, aka a “factory fat” not found anywhere in nature in this form.
Outrageously, the most beneficial and antimicrobial fat in coconut oil…lauric acid…is either partially or completely removed to make it.
Don’t fall for the scam!
Summary
In summary, while the idea of coconut oil capsules seems like a good one, it is impractical for weight loss purposes.
A huge number of capsules would be necessary to achieve a therapeutic dose.
Practically speaking, coconut oil capsules would only be helpful in two situations.
First, when traveling in order to avoid the potential for an oily mess in your luggage.
Secondly, for a gradual build-up of dosage to the point where the body’s metabolism and detoxification mechanisms can handle it.
At that point, switching to coconut oil off the spoon or blended into a smoothie or hot beverage would be the most appropriate and budget-friendly method for consumption.
Remember, therapeutic weight loss dosages of 3-6 tablespoons per day are what is necessary to achieve results. This is simply not practical with capsules!
I have recently started taking 2 coconut capsules before each
Meal and i gained weight. Should i start taking the coconut
Oil in jar? Or discontinue diet?
2 coconut oil capsules before each meal likely is not doing anything. You need a minimum of 1 tbl before each meal (15 capsules) to achieve appetite suppression. Did you read the article? This is why it’s probably best to take it off the spoon or mixed into a hot beverage because 15 capsules is A LOT.
Hi I was wondering if it’s ok to take coconut oil at night will it still burn fat
I would not recommend coconut oil before bed as it is very energizing for many people.
Very helpful information. I’ve just started using coconut oil and this helps me understand how much I need. I was also considering MCT oil but now I am reconsidering because of the information you provided. Thank you.
This morning I put my 1.5 tablespoon of cooking nut oil along with the same amount of fresh coconut in my oatmea, instead of the cinannomn and honey I generally use and it taste great. Do you think doing this makes the use less potent.
You can mix the coconut oil with honey and/or spices if you like. It does not reduce potency but adding the honey does add calories.
where do you find 5 gallons of cocnut oil that is organic?
The only 5 gal quantifities I’ve found are processed with hexane and lose a couple fatty acids, stearic, and lauryl, if I remember correctly.
Thank you for this information Sarah, I always learn something new from you. I was wondering- I take baths every day and then put 3-4 TBL coconut oil over my whole body. Does the body absorb the coconut oil as well when putting it on the skin as orally? I don’t really like the taste of the oil as much so it is easier for me to just put it on my body.
Glad you enjoyed the article Severin. Not sure about the absorption of coconut oil through the skin as I have not seen any research to that effect. If you feel that it is beneficial for you and you enjoy it, i.e., seeing good results, then stay with it. It surely is a wonderful moisturizer at the very least.
Severin, I’ve heard that your body absorbs something like 60-65% of what is applied to it. Thus, the encouragement to switch from chemically toxic items to more DIY bath & body items using natural ingredients. I also apply coconut oil after a shower (or a coconut oil blend scented with essential oils). Your question is whether topical application is as effective as internal consumption. My experience is not that I’ve noticed, though weight loss is not my intent for topically using coconut oil. My personal opinion is use on the outside to moisturize the skin and help heal rashes and wounds and also consume the oil to heal the body from the inside. Weight loss (which I have noticed when taking internally) is a bonus but not a main reason why I use coconut oil.
HTH
Absolutely LOVE all your articles you write! Thank you so much for all the awesome information you give us!
So nice of you to say Holly. Thank you 🙂
Thanks for the info. The pills seemed tempting. I still have a nice pull over sweatshirt that is stained because I tried using some of my coconut oil in the car. They would also gross my wife out a little less. I usually just eat a tablespoon or two right out of the jar.
I think Ill just start mixing it in warm water like you advise. I never thought about doing that before.
What I was wondering, Sarah, is whether it would be worthwhile to take caprylic acid capsules. Since some vendors are selling “brain octane” MCT oil that is claimed to be 18x more beneficial than coconut oil (at a price three times that of coconut oil), one can buy caprylic acid capsules for under $10 and get straight caprylic acid instead of 70% in the “octane” MCTs. What do you think?
I don’t think this is wise. I would stick with virgin coconut oil as lauric acid is the most beneficial fat in coconut oil. If pure coconut oil is a problem digestively as it is so very powerful and anti-microbial, start with small amounts and work your way up instead of shortchanging yourself with caprylic acid only … how could it possibly be 18X better than coconut oil in its whole food form when there’s no lauric acid there? That “brain octane” line sounds like a marketing ploy to me! Over the long term, I have not observed a single instance where using a fractionated food is more beneficial than the real thing in its whole form.
Taking a whole food and breaking it up into its components and selling them piece-meal combined with aggressive marketing is the oldest trick in the book for the food processing industry for maximizing profits. Don’t fall for it.
Can we get the same benefit by just eating young coconut meat? or even ground or shredded mature coconut?
Eating young coconut meat or shredded mature coconut is wonderful and healthful, but you would need to eat far too much coconut meat to get the 3-6 TBL per day of the oil (contained in the meat) for weight loss purposes.