Table of Contents[Hide][Show]
The conundrum of edamame, green and natural whole food, but one that is not healthy to eat, and why avoiding it no matter if fresh, frozen, or dry roasted is the best policy.
Edamame is a common feature on nearly every aisle of health food stores these days. A variety of packages featuring dry roasted, raw, steamed/chilled, or fresh edamame pods entice shoppers into thinking this appealingly sweet-tasting bean can help them reach their health goals.
Even supermarkets and warehouse stores are cashing in on the edamame craze. Shoppers find conventional varieties displayed with the freezer foods next to less enticing bags of broccoli, carrots, and peas.
What is Edamame
Edamame comes from harvesting immature green soybeans that are grouped together in pods much like green peas.
Preparation involves first cutting the pods on the ends and then steaming, boiling, or microwaving.
Boiling typically involves salting the water as well.
If steamed or microwaved, the salt is added after cooking with the soft green beans removed from the pods.
Edamame is usually served salted and cold as an appetizer in Japanese restaurants.
Green soya is also found in modern cuisine from China, Korea, and Hawaii, although the latter is largely due to Japanese influence rather than ancestral Polynesian traditions.
If frozen, fresh edamame is blanched first before packaging.
Historical Use in Asia
It seems to make sense that edamame would be a traditional food since it is unprocessed and simple to prepare.
Historical references appear to bear this out as the earliest documented reference for the word edamame occurred in 1275 AD when the Japanese monk Nichiren wrote a note thanking a parishioner for the gift of “edamame” left at the temple.
However, it was not known if this edamame was for consumption or for simple crop rotation purposes.
Kaayla Daniel PhD, The Naughty Nutritionist writes in her article What’s Edamame? And Other Questions about Green Vegetable Soybeans that historian William Shurtleff of the Soyfoods Center in Lafayette, CA, knows of no early references to green vegetable soybeans in China. Further, she writes:
An herbal guide from 1406 (Ming Dynasty) indicates the whole pods of young soybeans could be eaten or ground for use with flour, but it recommended such uses only during times of famine. A Materia Medica from 1620 recommends edamame, but only for the medicinal purpose of killing “bad or evil chi.” By 1929, however, edamame was definitely on some menus. William Morse of the USDA reported on a field trip to China that “as early as May, small bundles of plants with full grown pods were seen on the market. At the present time the market is virtually flooded with bundles of plants with full grown pods, the seeds of which are also full grown. The pods are boiled in salt water and the beans eaten from the pods.”
Soy as Rotation Crop
Dr. Daniel also disputes the claims by the soy industry that Asians have consumed this legume for 5,000 or even 10,000 years. She says that digging into anthropology and history texts absolutely does not support this common claim.
The oldest soyfoods, miso and tofu [bean curd] date back only about 2,500 years. Contrary to popular belief, soy was not eaten as a food 5,000 years ago, but it was highly regarded for its role in crop rotation.
Green and Natural But Not Healthy
Looking a bit like a cross between cannellini beans and green peas, edamame seems like a dream come true for a parent seeking healthy snack alternatives. Children gobble them up by the handful due to their addictive sweetness, and adults who prefer salty snacks can chow down on the dry roasted versions available in large, economy-sized bags.
While simple and quick to prepare and even easier to eat, edamame simply does not make the grade as a food that is healthy to eat on a regular basis.
One big reason why is because manufacturers source most edamame in the United States from genetically modified soybeans. They do not label these GMOs in North America as of this writing. Hence, even alert shoppers are frequently unaware of their presence in the foods they buy.
Most countries in the rest of the world require the labeling of GMOs. So, edamame is not usually GMO in those locations because consumers generally regard the identification of GMO ingredients on the label as akin to a skull and crossbones.
GMO Edamame Beans
Beware that most edamame served in Japanese restaurants and featured on salad bars in North America is also GMO! So enjoying that edamame appetizer before your meal at the local sushi joint isn’t the healthy first course that most presume it to be.
GMO soy is not good for your health even when it is green and unprocessed.
Scientific Research
Some of the most worrisome animal studies to date that should give any edamame lover pause include:
- A study of GMOs reported in the June 2013 issue of the peer-reviewed Journal of Organic Systems involved research conducted over 22.7 weeks using 168 newly weaned pigs in a commercial U.S. piggery. One group of 84 pigs ate a diet that incorporated genetically modified (GMO) soy and corn, and the other group of 84 pigs ate an equivalent non-GMO diet. The pigs that ate genetically modified soy and corn had a higher rate of severe stomach inflammation…32% of GMO-fed pigs compared to 12% of non-GMO-fed pigs. The inflammation was worse in GMO-fed males compared to nonGMO fed males by a factor of 4.0. GMO-fed females compared to non-GMO-fed females by a factor of 2.2. (1)
- Scientists at the Russian Academy of Sciences reported between 2005 and 2006 that female rats fed GMO soy produced excessive numbers of severely stunted pups. More than half of the litter died within three weeks, and the surviving pups were completely sterile. (2)
- Russian research from 2010 found that hamsters fed GMO soy for two years (over three generations) developed sterility. In addition, the pups that did get born suffered from slow growth and a high mortality rate. Most disgustingly, the third generation of hamsters raised on GMO soy developed unnatural and profuse hair growth in their mouths (3).
Profuse hair growth in the mouth … from eating GMO soy for only 3 generations? Yes, this is what the Russian researchers were horrified to discover. No wonder Russia has imposed a ban on all GMOs essentially kicking Monsanto to the curb.
What About Organic?
Ok, so you know all about the dangers of GMO soy and edamame. You’ve changed your buying habits and source only organic. Isn’t this a better choice?
Yes, it is definitely better and avoids the potential for chronic health problems observed in animal studies involving GMO soy.
However, even organic edamame presents a health threat when consumed on a regular basis. This is due to the high amount of hormone-disrupting phytoestrogens and anti-nutrients called protease inhibitors (primarily trypsin). These anti-nutrients are present even when picked young and green as edamame.
While eating edamame raw is the biggest no-no, cooking the pods doesn’t do enough to resolve these issues either. Cooking does little to reduce the phytoestrogens in edamame. Protease inhibitors remain virtually the same as well.
For decades, the USDA and other researchers put their efforts into finding safe and inexpensive ways to deactivate these protease inhibitors which wreak havoc with both digestion and the pancreas. Boiling, roasting, and steaming help, but don’t do enough.
The only way that comes close to neutralizing them is via traditional fermentation. Manufacturers use this method to make healthy forms of soy such as miso, tempeh, and natto.
Since the preparation of edamame involves only light cooking in most cases, you can count on most of the anti-nutrients remaining. All of the hormone-disrupting plant estrogens are present as well.
How Green Soya Disrupts Digestion
With regard to the green bean’s effect on digestion, the protease inhibitors present in high amounts in edamame suppress some of the key enzymes that help digest protein.
Because these inhibitors block the protease enzyme needed to digest protein, the pancreas has to work overtime to produce more. If this happens only occasionally, the pancreas quickly recovers, no big deal.
But if a person consumes edamame frequently and in large amounts, there is no recovery period. This leads to an increase in both the number of pancreatic cells (hyperplasia) and the size of those cells (hypertrophy). Combine that with frequent drinking of soya milk or foods containing soy protein isolate, and you’ve really got problems!
Pancreatic hypertrophy and hyperplasia in humans result in the loss of the ability to secrete sufficient enzymes. Insufficient enzyme production by the pancreas means digestive distress for adults and growth problems for children.
Irvin Liener, PhD, professor emeritus at the University of Minnesota and the world’s leading expert on anti-nutrients and toxins in plant foods, has a warning for those who might eat edamame frequently:
Soybean trypsin inhibitors do in fact pose a potential risk to humans when soy protein is incorporated into the diet.
Hormone Imbalance
Below are just a few of the many studies on how plant estrogens (also called isoflavones or phytoestrogens) in soy (edamame too) is can disrupt hormonal balance:
- Isoflavones (phytoestrogens) genistein and daidzein in soy appear to stimulate existing breast cancer growth. This indicates a risk of consuming soy products if a woman has breast cancer. (Annals of Pharmacotherapy 2001 Sep;35(9):118-21)
- Direct evidence that isoflavones genistein and daidzein suppress the pituitary-thyroid axis. This change occurs in only 3 three weeks in middle-aged rats fed 10 mg soy isoflavones per kilo. This compares with rats eating regular rat chow. (Experimental Biology and Medicine 2010 May;235(5):590-8)
- Don’t eat edamame or any other form of soy either when you are pregnant ladies! Scientific research demonstrates that the developing male fetus exposed to soy phytoestrogens may suffer from higher susceptibility to prostate cancer later in life. (Prostate 1994;24(2):67-78)
- A study of 12 men aged 18 years and older experienced a 19% drop in serum testosterone. This occurred in only 28 days when they were supplemented with 56 grams of soy protein. (Prev 2007;16:829—33)
As you can see by some of the dates of these studies, this information has been known for years. Yet, this food is still relentlessly pushed as healthy by the plant-based eating crowd.
Let’s look at some of the other risks from this “health food” that is nothing of the sort.
Precancerous Changes to Breast Tissue
Possibly the most worrisome research regarding soy consumption is the precancerous changes to breast tissue that can occur over time.
If you want to know the truth about how an edamame habit can harm your breast health, Breast Cancer Boot Camp, coauthored with William B. Hobbins MD, Sellens provides striking, irrefutable visual evidence of adverse, precancerous effects on the breasts from estrogenic foods like edamame.
Your breasts don’t lie! These pictures of precancerous breasts from eating estrogenic foods will have you rethinking your edamame consumption in a hurry if the green bean is your go-to snack.
Sprouted is Worse!
According to Kaayla Daniel PhD, a world-renowned soy expert who has appeared on the Dr. Oz Show among others, and authored the must-read The Whole Soy Story: The Dark Side of America’s Favorite Healthfood, sprouted edamame is worse than unsprouted.
She says:
I would not recommend sprouting soybeans as it concentrates the toxins. Long-term fermentation neutralizes them, but short-term sprouting concentrates them.”
Love Edamame? Here’s What to Do!
If you love edamame and want to toss some in your salad, go ahead. A few here and there aren’t going to cause any problems barring the presence of a soy allergy.
But … don’t go munching it like popcorn and developing a regular snacking habit of eating a bowl or several handfuls at a time.
Most especially, edamame is not a good snack to give to growing children (soy formula is a health disaster too) or hormonal adolescents going through puberty.
Even adults including menopausal women would be well advised to avoid eating it on a regular basis.
Make sure if you enjoy a handful of edamame from time to time that it is always cooked and labeled organic.
This means skipping the edamame appetizer at restaurants in North America no matter how hungry you are. Wait for the main course or order another appetizer because chances are very good it is GMO.
Remember…hairy mouths in hamsters within three generations of eating GMO soy! Most edamame in the United States is genetically modified. Spare your grandchildren friends!
A review of more recent literature doesn’t paint the same scary picture of soy, although it is admitted that there has been uncertainty due to the “intricacy of soy’s effects on the body”. Apparently, “soy isoflavones can bind to estrogen receptors in the body and cause either weak estrogenic or anti-estrogenic activity.”
From the Harvard School of Public Health
“Soy is a unique food that is widely studied for its estrogenic and anti-estrogenic effects on the body. Studies may seem to present conflicting conclusions about soy, but this is largely due to the wide variation in how soy is studied. Results of recent population studies suggest that soy has either a beneficial or neutral effect on various health conditions. Soy is a nutrient-dense source of protein that can safely be consumed several times a week, and probably more often, and is likely to provide health benefits—especially when eaten as an alternative to red and processed meat.” ~ https://nutritionsource.hsph.harvard.edu/soy/
Milk has estrogen (whole milk contains more than skim) – but soy has phytoestrogen. How it was explained to me was that animal estrogens have a non-negotiable impact on the body whereas phytoestrogens are adaptogenic and can be anti-estrogenic when the body has too much estrogen and is a mild source of estrogen when it is needed by the body.
“more recent research” is a synonym for “science for sale”. Did you learn nothing from the last 3 years???
It is the OLDER research that is actually more reliable for objectivity!
Stay brainwashed, stay hormonally disrupted. Your choice.
Who do you suppose is funding research in favor of plant-based human soy consumption when it is only like 6% of soy agriculture? Granted, 13% of cultivated soy goes to soybean oil for omnivorous junk food…but that’s not exactly relevant to the discussion.
Upwards of 77% of soy is grown for animal agriculture.
Who is conspiring to rig these studies???
Big Pharma who profits enormously from the detrimental and intractable hormone disruption from a public duped into eating a lot of soy thinking it is “healthy”.
I think this is an exaggeration…. Most of my Japanese friends eat everyday soya products and they never have issues with them nor healthy problems like we do here in US.
If they eat small condimental amounts that are fermented as traditionally done (such as natto consumed everyday in some areas of Japan), that is in line with ancestral use and not problematic.
What about Edamame bean flour? I recently saw they sell edamame pasta made of edamame flour so wondering if the process of making it flour, then drying it and ultimately boiling it to make the pasta would be less bad? (It’s also organic).
That is a hard no!
Can I assume that Tofu is also un-healthy?
Yes, tofu is also toxic. Even the sprouted tofu. https://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/tofu-bean-curd/
My granddaughter was given soy formula. She’s now 5 years old. What should we be doing to improve her health?
Also, I think it’s utterly halarious that plant estrogen (phytoestrogen) and estrogen created by the human body are used synonymously.
It’s kinda like those Neanderthals that talk about kraft mac n cheese being one molecule away from being plastic or whatever. H2O2 is one molecule away from being water, but you’d die drinking it considering it’s Hydrogen Peroxide and it will literally burn your insides faster than 3 Daredevil Loaded Grillers from Tacobell ever could.
Or the people that claim 100% pure sodium is better than all this crap salt with fillers. News Flash: If you put of chunk of pure sodium in your mouth your lower mandible is going to be blown off your face faster than Lightning McQueen’s can say “Kachow” as he crosses the finish line for the Piston cup.
I guess all those pesticides in the environment that act as estrogen mimickers and screw up the hormones of animals (people too) is funny to you also? Sad. Critical thinking is clearly the other national deficit in this country.
I find it funny how Asians eat all these supposedly incredibly unhealthy foods like soy, tofu, soy sauce, white rice, etc. Yet they outrank Americans in health on almost every level. The Japanese are prime examples of this. They eat all of this “unhealthy” stuff and somehow they aren’t morbidly obese and dying at the age of 45. In fact, they are living much longer than those in the U.S and the instances of obesity are almost Null. And idk if anyone here’s ever compared the average middle aged Japanese/SE Asian/Korean woman to a middle aged American woman, but it’s no fucking contest, lmao. You can clearly tell who’s healthier.
I honestly think some of y’all need to put down the tinfoil hats and the fork while you’re at it. Eating a couple of roasted soybeans isn’t going to affect your hormones and make you turn into the blue berry kid from Willy Wonka. The fact that some of ya’ll eat more calories than a 6 month old heffer and then clutch your pearls over eating a handful a spoonful of tofu is what’s the problem with our vision of health in this society.
Peace.
Important to note that Asians eat these foods in small condimental amounts and historically, they were fermented. They are not consumed in large amounts like plant-based eating white Americans foolishly do. Asians and Africans (who eat a lot of goitrogenic millet in some areas) seem to have more resistance to thyroid problems than Caucasians as well…