Table of Contents[Hide][Show]
Reasons to reconsider preparing and running a marathon due to the long-term health risks that scientific research is beginning to uncover and medical professionals are increasingly warning their patients about. The dangers to cancer patients or those in remission is especially worrisome!
Have you ever noticed that marathon runners in the Olympics look overly thin and in some cases, even weak?
Have you ever wondered why marathons are considered beneficial in our society yet the first person that ever ran one collapsed and died immediately after?
Yeah, and Pheidippides was fit too, likely selected for his job as a herald due to his speed and distance running ability. He was not some ancient Greek version of the modern couch potato.
While life may be a marathon your training program should not be. Running a half or whole marathon or competing in a triathlon are all admirable goals. But there are many dangers associated with excessive endurance training.
Dating as far back as the 1970s, the misconception of mainstream training philosophies that 45 minutes to an hour or more a day of intense aerobic activity has led to an overtrained, unfit, immune-compromised exercising population.
Humans were not designed for movement at a chronically sustained high-intensity aerobic pace.
We’ve all seen it in the local gym–day in and day out, week after week Jane and John plod away on the treadmills and ellipticals or pedal themselves into exhaustion in spin classes. It has done nothing to shed the extra fat on their butts and guts let alone tone them. I have never been impressed by any of these results.
13 Health Risks from Marathon Running
What exactly are the problems caused by training for long periods of time at high intensities such as what occurs when preparing/running a marathon?
Even if you take care to eat plenty of clean grassfed collagen and regularly take natural sources of Vitamins A/D and K2 to keep the bones and joints strong, many things can, in fact, start to break down from the continued punishment. This is particularly the case if you are over 30 . . . (1-5)
- Debilitating osteoarthritis . . . at a young age
- Permanent scarring of the heart muscle
- A weakening of the thyroid and adrenal glands
- Tendonitis and other repetitive strain injuries
- Recurrent upper respiratory infections
- Permanently damaged feet (my chiropractor says long-distance runners have some of the worst feet he’s ever seen)
- Increased oxidative damage (free radical production)
- Decreased fat metabolism
- Susceptibility to injury
- Loss of bone density
- Depletion of lean muscle tissue
- Hormone imbalances that are difficult to rectify (women)
- High refined carbohydrate intake promotes a dangerous level of continuous systemic inflammation.
Heart Surgeon Stops Doing Marathons
Dr. Peter McCullough, chief of cardiovascular research at Baylor Heart and Vascular Institute in Dallas, has completed 54 marathons, one in every state. But he stopped running marathons after examining research showing the potential dangers. He said:
I thought there was enough evidence that I wasn’t willing to pay the ultimate price.
I’m convinced that to go grind it out for hours on end at a steady pace is the wrong thing. Some experts are divided about this, and the concern is that it could dissuade some people from exercising, but we just can’t bury our heads about it. (2)
If you still are doubtful about the health risks from marathon running, consider how frequently one or more people die running them during competition. Even the very young are not immune. In 2019, a fit, healthy 22-year-old woman who played soccer for a nearby university died near the finish line of the Cleveland marathon. (6)
Excessive Cardio and Chronic Inflammation
The sad part of stories like this is that the intentions are good. They are doing this all in the name of “health”. They are certainly not out to destroy it.
Aside from the dangers mentioned above, why is high-intensity aerobic pursuit such a dead end?
One reason is the high level of carbohydrates consumed needed to sustain this activity leads to chronic inflammation.
You’ve probably seen it. Sally and Johnny are running a 5K so they load up on a big bowl of pasta the night before the big race. Then, they chow down on bagels and juice immediately after their 36 min run. A cascade of systemic inflammation follows.
More Running is NOT Better
Research presented at the American College of Cardiology Scientific Sessions in Washington showed a shocking finding that should give every marathoner pause.
Runners who average more than 20 miles a week don’t live as long as those who run less than 20 miles a week.
On average, those running more than 20 miles a week live about the same as people who don’t run much at all. (7)
Cancer Patients Particularly at Risk
Even worse are people in cancer remission logging mile after mile thinking it is going to keep cancer from returning. More often than not, it returns with a vengeance with a more dire prognosis than before.
Why? All the free radicals flooding their already weakened system from overexercising on a usually low-fat diet.
Folks with cancer courageously yet misguidedly doing half marathons and marathons are literally running themselves right into the grave.
Simply put, humans are not designed to exercise like this! We have 2 primary energy systems to power our muscles. The first relies on the slow-burning of fats keeping us fueled while at rest yet allowing for a continuous low-level aerobic activity such as walking, gardening, and day-to-day physical tasks. Fat is a very efficient fuel, stored and burned easily and cleanly when lots of oxygen is present.
Our second primary energy system that evolved is an ATP-fueled system that allows us to do intense loads of work in shorts bursts. It is our high octane fuel. Think of the woman that lifts a car off her child trapped beneath it. Or the person that sprints after a mugger to get their wallet back. In other words all-out effort for fewer than 20 seconds; flight or fight and life or death tasks and situations.
Our energy systems are far more complex than that but it boils to the fact that we were evolved to either move slowly and steadily or briefly and fast. We become both healthier and stronger by exercising and living in this manner.
Are Half-Marathons or Triathlons Dangerous?
All things being said, there are still people out there that want to run a half marathon or triathlon. Even at these shorter distances, they still need to be careful. (3)
The good news is that there is a better and smarter way to train for an endurance event while avoiding the negative risks mentioned above.
The days of logging mileage in excess of 20+ a week have become outdated and misinformed.
And so is the weak and skinny appearance of the stereotypical endurance athlete!
Combine Strength and Conditioning with Interval-based Training
Many are finding that by incorporating strength and conditioning workouts into their training routine along with shorter more interval-based training they are improving speed, power, and overall performance. This approach also reduces injury potential. Not to mention having a lot more free time, less pain and, quicker recovery, and no long-term scarring/damage to the heart.
This has been hotly debated but well documented in the past several years. Leading the pack in the defense is CrossFit Endurance’s, Brian MacKenzie. His training has many top-level endurance athletes setting personal records far beyond past efforts with a dramatic reduction in training time and mileage.
Fitness can and should be achieved without the need for pounding the pavement for miles on end, a huge daily time commitment, and a long list of extreme risks to health both short and long term.
References
(1) Potential Adverse Cardiovascular Effects from Excessive Cardiovascular Endurance Exercise
(2) Is Long-Distance Running Good for the Heart?
(3) Triathletes May Be Putting Their Heart at Risk
(4) Marathon Running Can Scar the Heart
(5) Exercise and Your Health (Myths about Exercise)
(6) 22-Year-Old Woman Dies During Cleveland Marathon
(7) More Running May Not Help You Live Any Longer
crazy4boys
I’m a new runner (okay, more of a jogger) and I just wanted to address this statement made by Paula: “Aside from the disastrous results mentioned above why is high intensity aerobic pursuit such a dead end? One reason is the high level of carbohydrates consumed needed to sustain this activity leads to chronic inflammation. You’ve all seen it–Sally and Johnny are running a 5 K so they load up on a big bowl of pasta the night before and chow down on bagels and juice immediately after their 36 min 5 K. Type 2 here we come.”
I’ve been on the GAPS diet the whole time I’ve been running (and a bit before) and have had no problems whatsoever with energy. I’m only “training” for a 5K so it’s not like I’m running the huge marathons, but it is possible to eat well and still run.
And the ToughMudder looks awesome. I don’t have time to train for the one closest to me, but it looks like something my husband would love to. I’m interested in seeing your training schedule. Maybe we’ll plan for it next year!
Jade Teta
Nice job Paula 🙂
Paula Jager
Wow, thank you Jade! I am a huge fan of your outstanding articles in On Fitness magazine.
Katie
Please show me real hard data on how marathon training/running causes the following, and I quote:
Debilitating osteoarthritis . . . at young ages
Tendonitis and other repetitive strain injuries
Recurrent upper respiratory infections
Increased oxidative damage (free radical production)
Decreased fat metabolism
Susceptibility to injury
Loss of bone density
Depletion of lean muscle tissue
Coupled with the common high refined carbohydrate intake promotes a dangerous level of continuous systemic inflammation.
Paula Jager
Only a portion of your quote is correct. I did not say nor imply that “marathon training/running” causes the above conditions but that “excessive endurance training” or “movement at a chronically sustained high intensity aerobic pace” is well known to lead to those conditions. I am talking about people that are logging 30-90+ miles a week, over and over a period of time. Cumulative damage prevails.
A few quick Google searches should pull you all the “very real hard data” you desire. And as for “high refined carbohydrate intake promoting systemic inflammation”, try reading Taubes book, Good Calories, Bad Calories. Lots of hard data there.
Michael Acanfora (@BayonneChiro) (@BayonneChiro) (@BayonneChiro)
How Running a Marathon Can Seriously Harm Your Health – The Healthy Home Economist
http://ow.ly/67Eav
watchmom3
As a recovering anorexic/bulimic from my younger days, (15 years wasted!) I can attest to the validity of this article. It is HIGHLY addictive to continually over-exercise and live in the “endorphin moment!” It has taken me years to get back to normal, with lots of twists and turns. The real moment of truth came when my sweet little daughters began worrying about their weight. It absolutely repeats itself in the next generation if you aren’t totally honest about why you exercise. Taking care of our bodies is a very good thing, even commanded by God. (He really does want what is best for us!) Moderation is key. I knew there would be some flack about this subject. Many aren’t ready to stop and look at whether or not they are addicted to the highs ( deceptive feelings of power) from this type of behavior. Thanks again Sarah! It is so good to get it out there and talk about it! Helps all of us!
Brittnee Turner Horting via Facebook
Obviously this isn’t true for every person who runs a marathon..but it can be for some. I have a friend who I would consider addicted to, not only marathons, but excercising. That’s all she does, she has let go of all her other interests and spends less time with her kids…just so she can excercise. She had a baby 3 weeks ago and is already back into it hard core…and I don’t think that’s quite enough time for your body to recover. I think it just becomes an obsession, and that’s when it’s dangerous.
Paul
It seems many of the people here who are arguing against the “overtraining” idea are missing the point. The author is not saying running a marathon or training to run one is ALWAYS BAD. Those of you saying “hey I run marathons but” are actually supporting her point – you mention interval training, not being emaciated, etc. You are training in the way she is saying is the BETTER way. One of you said “I don’t carbo load” – well that’s great, you are already following the author’s advice and hey look…it’s working great for you!
Kate
I have to disagree with you, I think the author thinks that marathons are bad for you across the board, because the professionals are too skinny so it must be harming everyone. That is at least the tone that I am picking up.
Paula Jager
Paul hit it spot on. While I have no desire to run a marathon some people do; done so with the proper diet and training and not in excess it can be accomplished without ill health effects. While many “professionals” are too skinny, a lot of amateurs are too fat. It’s the lack of strength and interval type training coupled with excessive carboydrate intake.
D.
quote from Melissa: “Sarah, you are brave and unapologetic and I am glad that you have the platform you do and the courage you show!”
Here here! I agree. Not all the subjects in the world are warm and fuzzy. But they need discussion and consideration, too.
Nick Richardson (@nr_fitness)
Definitely worth a read if you’re thinking long distance running will have you looking your best! http://t.co/tomnYhO
Melissa @ Dyno-mom
I am glad that you brought up this intersesting point. I have always been shocked by the appearance of marathon runners. I remember two women crossing the line at the Greek summer Olympics and how they shook and were horribly dehydrated from the heat. This, along with their frightening thin bodies, made sure they looked exactly like concentration camp victims crawling along the ground and I remember being troubled by it. I know this is controversial, but especially in women just a lack of body of fat is contrary to health. While I am not a “fat-vocate” I certainly know that fertility is a function of feminine health and when fat drops too much, women are infertile. This indicates a health problem. Sarah, you are brave and unapologetic and I am glad that you have the platform you do and the courage you show!